Ranking the Offseason Moves: The Good, The Bad, and The Willy Bloomquist

$180 million! Thats a lot of Junior Bacon Cheeseburgers!

$180 million! Thats a lot of Junior Bacon Cheeseburgers!

It’s been a busy offseason in the baseball world, with some splashy free agent signings; and to no one’s surprise it was the New York Yankees who were making the most noise. But it’s not always the big names that make the difference down the stretch (or at all: see Bedard, Erik) so a thorough examination of offseason moves is imperative to get a glimpse at who has a shot at winning it all in 2009.

Mark Teixeria (New York Yankees): Everyone seemed to know this one was coming except for the teams trying to sign him, (sorry Nationals and Orioles, their laughing with you, not at you), and in the end the best bat available ended up cashing in with the wealthiest team. The Yanks swooped in at the last minute and grabbed Sexy Texy for the discount price of $180 million over 8 years, roughly equivalent to the combined payroll of the Florida Marlins over the same period. The cost was steep, but Teixeria makes the Yankees an instant favorite to win the AL East and possibly their first world series since 2000. He is force at the plate, fresh off a .308-33-121 campaign with the Braves and Angels. In addition to his offense, Teixeria plays a Gold Glove first base, something the Yankees couldn’t exactly count on the past few years with Jason Giambi. At only 28 years old, Teixeria should be a key cog in the middle of the Yankees lineup for years to come.   Grade: A+

CC Sabathia (New York Yankees): The Yanks didn’t just grab the best bat on the market, they also got the most talented pitcher in lefty workhorse Sabathia. Off the strength of a historic second half that catapulted the Milwaukee Brewers into the postseason, Sabathia’s value was at an all time high. The Yankees seemed to agree, coughing up $161 million over seven years. If CC pitches like he did down the stretch, the Yankees got a major deal; but if he succumbs to injury or the allure of Dunkin’ Donuts, they could end up swallowing a lot of cash. At just 28 like Teixeria, Sabathia should be one of the AL’s best pitchers well into the next decade. His longterm health will determine the ultimate value of this deal as he has been piling on the innings over the past few years, but nonetheless he makes New York’s rotations one of the best in all of baseball. Grade: A-

Pat Burrell (Tampa Bay Rays): The Rays look to drop off a bit after a fantastic 2008 season, but the addition of Pat “The Bat” Burrell addresses a major need for Tampa, strikeouts and below-average defense a powerful right handed bat to protect Carlos Pena and Evan Longoria in the Rays lineup. He should serve as the team’s full time DH, and will probably hit around  .260 with 30 homeruns and 90 RBI’s, which are significant upgrades over the production at the DH position last year. At two years and only $16 million, “The Bat” should be well worth the gamble and will help the Rays to stay competitive in the AL East.  Grade: B+

Derek Lowe (Atlanta Braves): After losing out on Rafael Furcal and seeing John Smoltz jump to Boston, Braves management knew they needed to act fast and they grabbed the best remaining starter in Derek Lowe. Although he will turn 36 next season, Lowe remains a frontline starter and is coming off a season in which he won 14 games with a 3.24 ERA. Pitching in Turner Field should help this groundball machine chew up plenty on innings for Atlanta. He should be effective for a couple of years, but will likely decline towards the end of his 4 year/$40 million deal. Grade: B

Milton Bradley (Chicago Cubs): The mercurial Bradley has only two seasons of over 400 at-bats, so the Cubs are taking a huge gamble with this 3 year/$30 million deal. The question has never been talent with Bradley (he posted a line of .321-22-77-.436 OBP last season with Texas) but his career has been marked by injuries and off the field issues. He spent most of last season as a DH and was bothered by a litany of ailments throughout the season. If the Cubs are expecting him to get 500 at-bats from a spot in the outfield, they are sorely mistaken. Chicago will probably end up wishing they signed Parker Brothers for this price. Grade: C- 

Francisco Rodriguez (New York Mets): The New York Mets love to blow saves. Francisco Rodriguez, fresh off a record setting 62 save season, does not. As often happens, opposites attract, and the result was a 3 year/$37 million deal that the Mets hope can erase the painful memories of the last two seasons. Besides the saves, K-Rod also posted a 2.24 ERA and averaged more than a strikeout an inning but there has been a noticeable drop in his velocity the past few seasons and long-term health is an issue. Regardless, the Mets filled a major weakness of their ballclub, which should keep their fans happen for the first week of the season or so. Grade: B


How will Holliday fare in a pitcher's park?

How will Holliday fare in a pitcher's park?

Matt Holliday (Oakland Athletics): This move was a bit of a shocker as Oakland GM Billy Beane has never been one to take on big contracts and he is on the hook for over $10 million with Holliday next season, but is looking to add offense to his club and take a shot at winning the wild, wild weak AL West.  Holliday is a great hitter, base stealer and a stellar teammate and will provide a huge boost to Oakland’s anemic station-to-station offense. The two-time Silver Slugger should experience a dropoff in his numbers as he is moving from a hitter friendly park (Coors Field) to a field where fly balls go to die (McAfee Coliseum), but will still inject some much needed life into the Athletics. The A’s have one of the deepest farm systems in the game and could afford to part with the three players they gave up (Carlos Gonzalez, Huston Street and Greg Smith) knowing that they can either deal Holliday at the deadline or let him go at the end of the year and recieve draft picks. If Oakland’s young pitching staff can perform as expected, the A’s may make a run at the division crown. Grade: B+

Randy Johnson (San Francisco Giants): The Giants picked up a future hall-of-famer off the clearance rack with a one year/$8 million deal and add him to a formidable rotation that includes reigning NL Cy Young winner Tim Lincecum and star in the making Matt Cain. Although 45 and quickly losing gas on his fastball, the Big Unit was still effective last year going 11-10 with a 3.91 ERA and nearly a strikeout an inning. Just five wins short of 300, Johnson should help the Giants gain a measure of respectability if he can stay off the DL. Grade: A-

Raul Ibanez (Philadelphia Phillies): Ibanez was one of the few bright spots for the Mariners last season and was arguably their best player hitting .293 with 23 HRs and 110 RBIs, including a ridiculous August where he hit .396. Then again, being the best player on the M’s is kind of like being the most talented musician in Nickleback. Ibanez is already 36 and a liability in the field so a 3 year/$31.5 million deal seems pretty generous and will probably ending up costing Philly more than they gain. Raul is great in the clubhouse, but is sure to decline at the plate. Grade: C-

Willie Bloomquist (Kansas City Royals): The Royals continue their commitment to winning now with the signing of swiss army knife Willie Bloomquist, a player who can man any position in the field, but is more likely find Jimmy Hoffa than crack one out of the park. In 161 at-bats last season, Bloomquist managed exactly one extra base hit (a double) and 9 RBIs. The Royals expect him to compete for the starting second base job, but it is difficult to believe that they don’t have a player in the minors who could duplicate Bloomquist’s numbers for far less than the 2 year/$3.1 million deal he recieved. Quite simply, WTF?!?! Grade: F-

Kerry Wood (Cleveland Indians): Just one season removed from playing for the AL pennant the Indians fell off a cliff due in large part to a bullpen meltdown that would make even Heathcliff Slocumb cringe. Wood excelled in his first season as a closer with 34 saves and 84 punchouts in 66 innings. The former starter stills brings upper 90s heat and is dominant in short stretches, which should bring some stability to Cleveland’s bullpen. If he can stay healthy (a BIG if), the Indians scored a major deal with this 2 year/$20.5 million contract. Grade: B+

Jason Giambi (Oakland A’s): Giambi returns home to the team that drafted him after a torrid seven year affair with Kirk Radomski the Yankees, and should add some punch to a lackluster Athletics offense. While Giambi only hit .247 last season, he slugged 32 HRs and drove in 96 runs in only 458 at-bats and should be able to easily outpace Emil Brown’s production at DH. Giambi should be a great return on Oakland’s 1 year/$4 million investment and the addition of his facial hair and pseudo-mullet made this deal a no brainer. Grade: A-

A.J. Burnett (New York Yankees): The Yankees still had millions burning a hole in their pockets after the signing of CC, so they grabbed another Cy Young candidate in former Bluejay A.J. Burnett. He has some of the best stuff in the game and is coming off a season in which he won 18 games and punched out 231 batters, but the big question with Burnett is whether he can stay healthy over an extended period of time. The Yankees sure seemed to think so, investing 5 years/$82.5 million in him and giving the team one of the most dominant starting fives in recent history (apologies to any Texas Rangers pitching staff of the past 10 years). The addition of Burnett to a rotation including Sabathia, Joba Chamberlain, Andy Pettite, and Chien Ming Wang make the Yankees the team to beat in the AL East. Grade: B


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: